Shocking Dark Energy Findings Challenge the Standard Model of the Universe
A new map of cosmic expansion suggests that dark energy evolves over time, hinting that the universe doesn’t work the way we thought it did
DESI’s 3D map of the universe can show how dark energy may have evolved over time. Earth is at the center in this animation, and every dot is a galaxy.
For almost three decades, astronomers have believed that the universe is expanding faster and faster and that the acceleration of this growth is constant over time—driven by a mysterious force they call “dark energy.” Last April a survey by the Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument (DESI) published hints that dark energy may not be as constant as they’d assumed, adding to a pile of concerns that are already threatening the standard model of cosmology. Today Nadathur and his DESI collaborators unveiled their follow-up results publicly at the American Physical Society’s Global Physics Summit and in multiple preprint papers, further validating the omen.
After nearly tripling the researchers’ collection of galaxy coordinates, the new DESI analysis provides the strongest evidence yet that the rate of cosmic expansion fluctuates—finally shedding some light on dark energy, which scientists think constitutes about 70 percent of everything in the universe.
If you’re enjoying this article, consider supporting our award-winning journalism by subscribing. By purchasing a subscription you are helping to ensure the future of impactful stories about the discoveries and ideas shaping our world today.
Although the evidence still falls short of physicists’ benchmark for a “discovery,” experts say the new result leaves the standard model in dire straits. Making sense of an evolving dark energy would almost certainly involve amending the foundations of physics in order to unlock the true history and fate of our universe.
“It’s like hitting a vein of gold,” says Adam Riess, who shared the 2011 Nobel Prize in Physics for the discovery of dark energy and was not involved in the new work. Assuming the result holds up, “it says this investment that we’ve all been making that there was still more to learn is going to pay off.”
Cosmic Tug-of-War
Today the canonical story of cosmic evolution describes this tug-of-war between the unwavering push of dark energy and the gravitational pull of matter (including the vast reservoirs of invisible “cold dark matter” that supposedly glue galaxies together). This standard model paints a “crazy successful” picture of how the universe evolved from one second to 14 billion years old, despite the fact that 95 percent of the model’s contents are utterly unfamiliar, says Kevork Abazajian, an astrophysicist at the University of California, Irvine. “But it’s also broken.” A series of conflicting measurements about the expansion rate and the clumpiness of the cosmos have thrown cosmology into a conundrum.
Frozen Ripples in Space
Shortly after the big bang, the universe was a fireball of free-flying particles and light that sloshed around, creating pressure waves like those you’d get from tossing a rock into a pond. After around 380,000 years, everything had cooled enough for atoms to form, allowing light to flow freely without constantly bumping into other particles (this light is the cosmic microwave background radiation that we can still see today). Suddenly, the primordial pond froze over, preserving a patchwork of ripples, all about 490 million light-years across. These waves, known as baryonic acoustic oscillations, sowed the seeds for galaxies to come—offering astronomers today a handy standardized touchstone.
The Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument (DESI) maps the universe by collecting spectra from millions of galaxies and quasars.
Perched on the Quinlan Mountains in southern Arizona, DESI is designed to pick up those sound waves frozen in time. Its 5,000 dancing robotic arms trace out the patterns of galaxies, capturing more than 200,000 in a night. It then spits their light out into a spectrum, revealing the relative age of different clusters of galaxies. For objects more than nine billion light-years away, DESI detects matter by the way it soaks up light from supermassive black holes glowing in the background. At each slice of cosmic history, the team looks for traces of the ripples in the distribution of matter. Finally, by overlaying those measurements with observations of the cosmic microwave background and various supernovae surveys, the researchers can reconstruct a three-dimensional map of the universe’s expansion over the past 11 billion years.
Last April the 900-member DESI collaboration released the analysis of its first year of data, which showed some hints that the cosmic expansion rate didn’t line up perfectly with the standard model. But experts were hesitant to trust the signal from a brand-new experiment with limited observations. In this round, DESI has pinpointed nearly 15 million galaxies from more than 24,000 exposures—a few of which, observers suspect, were accidentally triggered by the telescope’s resident cat Mimzi stepping on the keyboard.
Days before the big reveal, a select few researchers quietly swapped in the true measurements and watched the plots slowly take shape. Uendert Andrade, a postdoctoral researcher at the University of Michigan, spent the following days mustering his best poker face and dodging colleagues’ attempts to pry the answer out of him. “It’s really kind of magical—you’re one of the few people in the world that know this,” he says.
On their own, the new DESI observations show a slight but statistically insignificant preference for an evolving dark energy. But when they are combined with other experiments’ data from supernovae surveys and the cosmic microwave background, the confidence that dark energy is indeed wavering approaches 99.997 percent—a compelling indication that’s just shy of the bar usually required to claim a physics discovery. Crucially, no matter which of those datasets are omitted, the results all point in the same direction. “You can remove one leg of the stool, and it still stands,” Riess says. “It passes the sniff test that I have for [taking] a result very seriously.”
Rewriting Physics
The analysis seems to suggest that dark energy transforms over time—appearing a tad weaker today than Einstein’s prediction and a tad stronger in the early universe. This progression has implications for the ultimate destiny of the universe: a dark energy that is too strong could eventually rip apart all atoms, and one that is too weak could lure everything to crunch inward.
After the unblinding, Lamman and a few dozen of her colleagues ran out to the beach to celebrate. Floating in the ocean, she gazed up at the blanket of stars and cried out at the sky, “We know your secret!”
Zack Savitsky is a freelance science journalist specializing in physics and astronomy.
Source: www.scientificamerican.com